So 3940/3286 (and now 5135?) seems to be a popular choice.
Why? What makes this pirate ship the best of the lot, particularly when compared to the current "Large Pirate Ship" (4290)?
-- Kenny
The 3940 is a bit bigger than the others and has more options to it. (options being you can mount more cannons on it - 8 in total but it only comes with 2 so you have to buy the other 6).
The rigging is not as complex as the older 3050 / 3053.
He might love the 4290 - you have to take into account many of the people on here are adults who like more scale realism as opposed to play value from the eyes of a preschooler. If I was that age I know I would love it. It's got lots of interactive things about it AND it's a big pirate ship. Honestly, what's not to love?!
There is a reason Playmobil got rid of the 3940 and changed to a different ship.
I would also suggest the 5736 (
http://store.playmobilusa.com/on/demandware.store/Sites-CA-Site/en_CA/Product-Show?pid=5736&cgid=Piraten). It is based on the original Playmobil pirate ship (same boat, different sails and colours) BUT it has a huge problem. The hold where you store your booty has no sides to it so all the small things (big too) get lost and you have dismantel the ship with a screw driver to get the little pieces out. There is a weight in the bottom of it for ballast and the little pices even get lodged under there. It's very frustrating. However the rigging is simple and the cannon is bg and easy to load.
All the ones that look like this:
http://store.playmobilusa.com/on/demandware.store/Sites-CA-Site/en_CA/Product-Show?pid=7518&cgid=Piraten are good. There is no hold to lose things under but there is a hold. They're smaller though.
One thing you have to think about is what would the pirates do? Maybe you need a couple ships so the pirates can battle someone else (the bad pirates, for instance).
My advice would be to get the 4290 for your child, get as many add-on sets as you can (ie lighthouse, raft w/octopus), etc, etc and let him have fun.
I would aslo suggest maybe getting some of the mermaid sets too and maybe the ghost pirates before you can't find them anymore.
Watch craigslist and see how many other pirate sets you can snatch up in the mean time.
One more thing - to you or I waiting 'till Christmas is only 6 months. To a 3 year old that is 1/6 of his entire lifetime of a wait.