Hi Robbie,
There are the usual US toy stores, Learning Express and TRU. And there is a toy store called Kidstown which has a lot of current stuff, though it's a bit overpriced. There is also one toy outlet (forgot the name) with a fair amount of stuff at ok prices. I would say, though, that for the most part, I get my playmobil from ebay, trading, and online retailers who have a wider variety and are cheaper.
Vermont is a beautiful place, especially if you like mountain views and fall color. The pace here is slower, too, and people are generally quite friendly. My dream is to live in the Pacific Northwest, but until I can I don't want to leave here (though every January I question that opinion!)
Cheers,
Red